Urban Decay
7.8Long-wear cult formulas with an edgy aesthetic
Best forPeople who prioritize makeup that doesn't budge through a full day or night out and want a foundation with 50 shades that is explicitly wear-tested for oily skin.
Scores — click any row to see our rationale
Shade Range & Color Accuracy▼8/10
Price & Value for Money▼7/10
Ingredient Quality & Skin Compatibility▼8/10
Availability & Where to Buy▼8/10
Pros
✓All Nighter Setting Spray ($36) is formulated specifically to prevent makeup oxidation and transfer over 16 hours — a claim that has been independently tested by multiple beauty editors and YouTubers
✓Stay Naked Foundation ($42) comes in 50 shades, matching Fenty's count and covering deep/dark tones with specific undertone options not available in narrower ranges
✓Available at both Sephora and Ulta — you can use loyalty points from either program, and return products to whichever store is closer
✓100% vegan and cruelty-free — uncommon for an LVMH brand given the parent company's China retail footprint; Urban Decay maintains the certification by not selling in mainland China
✓All Nighter Foundation ($42) uses a transfer-resistant formula that's specifically tested for oily skin — a meaningful claim given that most 'long-wear' formulas still break down on high-sebum areas
✓Naked Eyeshadow Palettes set a palette standard in 2010 that most brands still reference — the pigment quality and blendability in the Naked range has held up against newer competitors at the same price
Cons
✕The brand's edgy aesthetic — which built its reputation — now competes with a much more crowded alternative market; the aesthetic differentiation is less meaningful than it was 10 years ago
✕All Nighter Setting Spray has a strong alcohol content that can dry out skin over time — relevant for people with dry or dehydrated skin who use it daily
✕At $42 for Stay Naked Foundation, you're paying $4 more than Fenty for the same shade count without a clear formula advantage — the value argument depends heavily on the long-wear benefit
✕No skincare-forward ingredients in formulas — unlike ILIA (SPF 40 + vitamin C) or Rare Beauty (hyaluronic acid), Urban Decay products are makeup-only without skin benefit claims
✕The Naked Palette franchise has been partially discontinued — if you built your eye routine around specific Naked shades, supply is no longer guaranteed
Compare head-to-head