Which Game Subscriptions did Clientele compare?

We independently scored 8: Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, PC Game Pass, PlayStation Plus Premium, PlayStation Plus Extra, Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack, EA Play, Apple Arcade, Ubisoft+. Each is rated 0 to 10 on the same dimensions.

How does Clientele score Game Subscriptions?

Every option is rated 0 to 10 across 5 dimensions: Library Size, Value, Day-One New Releases, Platform Coverage, Extras & Perks. Each score is tied to a specific, verifiable fact, and scores are not influenced by affiliate relationships.

Home/Game Subscriptions

Game Subscriptions

Q: Which Game Subscriptions does Clientele rate highest?

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate is our highest-rated pick, scoring 9.0 out of 10 across 5 dimensions. Console and PC gamers who want the most complete subscription. Ultimate includes every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game on release day, EA Play, cloud gaming on Android and iOS, and online multiplayer in one subscription. Though new Call of Duty titles no longer launch day one.

Reviewed by the Clientele Research Team · Last checked 1 month ago (2026-08-03)

8 options

OUR PICK · 8 tested

Best overall

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Console and PC gamers who want the most complete subscription. Ultimate includes every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game on release day, EA Play, cloud gaming on Android and iOS, and online multiplayer in one subscription. Though new Call of Duty titles no longer launch day one.

SCORE9.0ELITE

✓Every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game is still included on release day. Starfield and Forza both launched directly into Game Pass.

✓Cloud gaming via xCloud streams to Android, iOS, and Samsung TVs. No console required to play the full library.

✓Price was cut from $29.99 to $22.99 in April 2026 after Xbox's new leadership admitted the service had gotten too expensive.

Try Game Pass Ultimate See full breakdown →

ALSO WORTH IT

SCORE7.7STRONG

Best for PC gamers

PC Game Pass

PC gamers who want day-one access to Xbox first-party games without paying for console or cloud gaming. At $13.99 per month, PC Game Pass costs about 61% of Ultimate's $22.99 while delivering the same core library.

Try PC Game Pass Details →

SCORE7.5STRONG

Best for families

Apple Arcade

Families and casual gamers who want a clean gaming experience. Every Apple Arcade game is ad-free with no in-app purchases. The only major game subscription where you never encounter monetization inside a game.

Try Apple Arcade Details →

All game subscriptions · 8 options

SORT

MIN SCORE

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

$22.99/mo. Xbox + PC + cloud + EA Play

Library9.5

Value8.0

Day-One8.5

Platforms9.5

Extras9.5

9.0Open →

PC Game Pass

$13.99/mo. 400+ PC games day one

Library9.0

Value9.0

Day-One8.5

Platforms5.0

Extras7.0

7.7Open →

PlayStation Plus Premium

$19.99/mo. PS library + classics + cloud streaming

Library9.0

Value7.0

Day-One4.0

Platforms8.0

Extras7.5

7.1Open →

PlayStation Plus Extra

$16.99/mo. 400+ PS4/PS5 games

Library8.5

Value7.5

Day-One4.0

Platforms7.0

Extras6.5

6.7Open →

Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack

$49.99/yr. Retro classics + DLC packs

Library7.5

Value7.5

Day-One2.0

Platforms5.0

Extras7.0

5.8Open →

EA Play

$5.99/mo. 100+ EA games + 10-hour trials

Library6.5

Value8.0

Day-One3.0

Platforms7.0

Extras7.0

6.3Open →

Apple Arcade

$6.99/mo. 200+ games, zero ads, zero IAP

Library7.0

Value8.5

Day-One7.0

Platforms8.5

Extras6.5

7.5Open →

Ubisoft+

$17.99/mo. All Ubisoft games day one on PC and Xbox

Library5.5

Value5.5

Day-One9.0

Platforms8.0

Extras5.0

6.6Open →

LEADERBOARD · OVERALL SCORE

#	NAME	BEST FOR	SCORE
1	Xbox Game Pass Ultimate	Console and PC gamers who want the most complete subscription. Ultimate includes every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game on release day, EA Play, cloud gaming on Android and iOS, and online multiplayer in one subscription. Though new Call of Duty titles no longer launch day one.	9.0
2	PC Game Pass	PC gamers who want day-one access to Xbox first-party games without paying for console or cloud gaming. At $13.99 per month, PC Game Pass costs about 61% of Ultimate's $22.99 while delivering the same core library.	7.7
3	Apple Arcade	Families and casual gamers who want a clean gaming experience. Every Apple Arcade game is ad-free with no in-app purchases. The only major game subscription where you never encounter monetization inside a game.	7.5
4	PlayStation Plus Premium	PlayStation owners who want the deepest catalog and access to PS1, PS2, and PSP classics. Premium adds cloud streaming, a retro library, and 2-hour game trials on top of Extra's 400+ modern games.	7.1
5	PlayStation Plus Extra	PlayStation owners who want a large on-demand library without paying for features they won't use. Extra's 400+ game catalog covers most major PS4 and PS5 third-party releases at $3 per month less than Premium.	6.7
6	Ubisoft+	Ubisoft franchise fans on PC or Xbox who buy multiple Ubisoft games per year. At $17.99 per month, Ubisoft+ Premium includes day-one access to every new Ubisoft release plus all DLC and season passes, on PC via Ubisoft Connect or standalone on Xbox Series X\|S and Xbox One.	6.6
7	EA Play	Sports game fans and EA franchise followers who want the cheapest entry point. At $5.99 per month, EA Play is the most affordable major game subscription and includes 10-hour full-game trials of every new EA release.	6.3
8	Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack	Nintendo fans who want access to the retro library and included DLC. At $4.17 per month annually, NSO + Expansion Pack includes Animal Crossing: New Horizons Happy Home Paradise, Mario Kart 8 Booster Course Pass, and 500+ classic games.	5.8

WHAT MOVED

↓

EA Play, Value

9.0→8.0

1 month ago

↑

Ubisoft+, Platform Coverage

6.0→8.0

1 month ago

•

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate, Initial publish

9.4→9.4

2 months ago

MOST RECENT CHANGE

EA Play, Value

9.0→8.0

EA raised EA Play's price from $4.99 to $5.99 per month in May 2024, weakening the value case that previously cited an unchanged price.

How we score game subscriptions

Library Size

Total number of available games and quality and diversity of the catalog. Higher means more to play across more genres.

Value

Price per month relative to what you get. Library depth, day-one access, and extras factored against cost. Higher means more per dollar.

Day-One New Releases

Whether major new first-party games are included in the subscription on release day. Higher means you can skip buying new games outright.

Platform Coverage

How many devices and platforms the subscription works on. Console, PC, mobile, cloud, TV. Higher means more flexibility.

Extras & Perks

Additional benefits beyond game access. Cloud gaming, online multiplayer, member discounts, exclusive content, DLC. Higher means more included.

OTHER CATEGORIES

Online Brokerages Red Light Devices Password Managers Credit Cards Grocery Delivery Daily Newsletters VPN Services Web Hosting Meal Kit Delivery Video Game Publishers Makeup Brands Skincare Brands Beauty Stores Cinemas Streaming Services AI Tools Fitness Trackers Red Light Glasses

clntl may earn a commission when you subscribe through links on this page. This does not affect our scores or rankings.