MAC Cosmetics
7.5Pro artist staple with 99 shades and deep-tone expertise
Best forPeople with deep or dark skin tones who have historically struggled to find foundation shades with accurate undertones, and want access to professional-grade products in 500+ store locations.
Scores — click any row to see our rationale
Shade Range & Color Accuracy▼10/10
Price & Value for Money▼7/10
Ingredient Quality & Skin Compatibility▼3/10
Availability & Where to Buy▼10/10
Pros
✓Studio Fix Fluid comes in 99 shades — if you can't find your match here, you won't find it anywhere at this price point ($35)
✓Every standalone MAC store is staffed by trained makeup artists who will match your foundation and apply it for free — no appointment needed at most locations
✓The brand has been the default for professional makeup artists for 40+ years — products are formulated to perform under stage lighting, photography, and long events
✓Back-to-MAC recycling program: return 6 empty primary packaging pieces and get a free full-size lipstick ($22 value) — a concrete sustainability incentive
✓Fix+ Setting Spray ($30) is a backstage staple that blends out powder, adds skin-like dewiness, and extends wear — has no direct formula equivalent at this price
✓500+ standalone stores mean you can walk in, get professionally shade-matched, and walk out with the right product the same day — in most major cities worldwide
Cons
✕NOT cruelty-free certified — MAC's China sales disqualify it from all major international cruelty-free certifications; this is a non-negotiable limitation for animal welfare-focused shoppers.
✕The brand's aesthetic is very professional and artist-facing — the product line is overwhelming for everyday buyers who just want a foundation and a blush without navigating 300 SKUs
✕Studio Fix is a medium-to-full coverage, matte-finish formula — it looks very 'done' and isn't suited to the 'your skin but better' look many buyers currently want
✕No meaningful clean beauty positioning — formulas are professional grade but use conventional cosmetic ingredients without EWG screening or vegan verification
✕Online shade-matching is genuinely difficult given 99 options — without visiting a store, most people will need to order multiple shades and return the mismatches
Compare head-to-head
MAC Cosmetics vs Fenty BeautyMAC Cosmetics vs Rare BeautyMAC Cosmetics vs Charlotte TilburyMAC Cosmetics vs GlossierMAC Cosmetics vs ILIA BeautyMAC Cosmetics vs Kylie CosmeticsMAC Cosmetics vs NARSMAC Cosmetics vs Milk MakeupMAC Cosmetics vs e.l.f. CosmeticsMAC Cosmetics vs Urban DecayMAC Cosmetics vs Huda Beauty