Skip to main content
ClienteleCLNTL
Home/Game Subscriptions/PlayStation Plus Extra vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

PlayStation Plus Extra vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Head-to-head across 5 dimensions. Speed, privacy, value, and more. Scores are independent and not influenced by affiliate relationships.

Reviewed by the Clientele Research Team · Last checked 1 month ago (2026-08-03)
PlayStation Plus Extra
$16.99/mo. 400+ PS4/PS5 games
6.7/10
vs
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
$22.99/mo. Xbox + PC + cloud + EA Play
9.0/10WINNER
SCORE BREAKDOWN
DIMENSION
PlayStation Plus Extra
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
EDGE
Library
Total number of available games and quality and diversity of the catal…
8.5
9.5
Xbox ↑
Value
Price per month relative to what you get. Library depth, day-one acces…
7.5
8.0
Xbox ↑
Day-One
Whether major new first-party games are included in the subscription o…
4.0
8.5
Xbox ↑
Platforms
How many devices and platforms the subscription works on. Console, PC,…
7.0
9.5
Xbox ↑
Extras
Additional benefits beyond game access. Cloud gaming, online multiplay…
6.5
9.5
Xbox ↑
Overall Score
6.7
9.0
Xbox wins
OUR VERDICT
PlayStation Plus Extra

Best for: PlayStation owners who want a large on-demand library without paying for features they won't use. Extra's 400+ game catalog covers most major PS4 and PS5 third-party releases at $3 per month less than Premium.

Get PS Plus Extra
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Best for: Console and PC gamers who want the most complete subscription. Ultimate includes every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game on release day, EA Play, cloud gaming on Android and iOS, and online multiplayer in one subscription. Though new Call of Duty titles no longer launch day one.

Try Game Pass Ultimate
ALSO COMPARE