Skip to main content
ClienteleCLNTL
Home/Grocery Delivery Services/Shipt vs DoorDash

Shipt vs DoorDash

Head-to-head across 6 dimensions. Speed, privacy, value, and more. Scores are independent and not influenced by affiliate relationships.

Reviewed by the Clientele Research Team · Last checked 22 days ago (2026-07-15)
Shipt
Target-owned same-day delivery with 130+ retail partners
5.0/10
vs
DoorDash
Restaurant app that also delivers groceries and convenience
6.8/10WINNER
SCORE BREAKDOWN
DIMENSION
Shipt
DoorDash
EDGE
total cost (fees
How much extra you pay on top of the grocery price. Delivery fees, ser…
4.0
5.0
DoorDash ↑
store selection
How many stores and retailers you can order from, and whether those st…
7.0
8.0
DoorDash ↑
delivery speed
How fast your groceries arrive. And how often the order shows up compl…
6.0
7.0
DoorDash ↑
membership value
Whether the annual or monthly subscription fee pays for itself, and wh…
5.0
7.0
DoorDash ↑
app experience
How smooth the ordering process is and whether customer support resolv…
3.0
8.0
DoorDash ↑
healthy selection
Whether the service surfaces health-focused retailers and organic/diet…
5.0
6.0
DoorDash ↑
Overall Score
5.0
6.8
DoorDash wins
OUR VERDICT
Shipt

Best for: Frequent Target shoppers who want same-day delivery and spend $200+ per month at Target. The $99 per year membership breaks even at roughly 5–6 orders and the integration with Target Circle rewards is a real perk.

Try Shipt
DoorDash

Best for: People who already use DoorDash for restaurant delivery and want to add grocery and convenience store runs under one DashPass subscription. You get both use cases for $9.99 per month without paying for a second membership.

Try DoorDash
ALSO COMPARE