Apple Watch
SCORE5.8FAIR
The most full-featured smartwatch, but it only works with an iPhone
BEST FORiPhone owners who want one device that handles fitness tracking, notifications, apps, and payments without carrying a second gadget.
Reviewed by the Clientele Research Team · Last checked today (2026-07-13)
Scores — click any row to see our rationale
Subscription & Total Cost▼7/10
Battery Life & Charging Hassle▼4/10
Tracking Accuracy▼7/10
Form Factor & Smartwatch Features▼9/10
Platform Lock-In (iPhone vs Android)▼2/10
PROS
✓Core health and fitness tracking — heart rate, workouts, sleep — doesn't require any subscription to use
✓Series 11 and Ultra 3 include an FDA-cleared ECG app and blood oxygen sensing, features most fitness bands don't offer
✓Full smartwatch functionality: its own app store, Apple Pay for contactless payments, and cellular models that work without your phone nearby
✓Deepest notification and app integration of any device here if you're already using an iPhone for calls, messages, and apps
✓Fall detection and crash detection features function as a safety net beyond fitness tracking
✓Apple Fitness+ is entirely optional — you're not paying extra just to see your daily activity rings or workout summaries
CONS
✕Requires an iPhone to set up and use — it has no Android compatibility at all, unlike Fitbit, Garmin, or Samsung Galaxy Watch
✕SE is rated around 18 hours of battery life (Series 11 stretches to 24 with sleep tracking), meaning daily charging either way and a tighter window for continuous sleep tracking than ring/band competitors
✕Apple Fitness+ ($9.99/mo or $79.99/yr) is a separate subscription for guided workout video content, and it's only bundled into the most expensive Apple One tier (Premier, $37.95/mo)
✕Model lineup (SE, Series, Ultra) and pricing change yearly, making it harder to know if you're buying last year's tech at full price
✕Charging every night means you either interrupt sleep tracking or have to build a mid-day top-up charging habit
✕Cellular models carry an added monthly carrier fee on top of the device price if you want to use data without your phone nearby
YOU MIGHT ALSO CONSIDER
Garmin7.4
Free core tracking, with some models lasting weeks per charge
View Garmin →Polar7.0
A Finnish endurance-sport watch brand with no subscription and chest-strap-grade accuracy claims
View Polar →Fitbit6.2
Google-owned step and sleep tracker with some features locked behind a paid tier
View Fitbit →